Perpetual Research

Mar 09, 2010,12:55 PM
 

Showing a computer rendering of the watch to the world is one thing; developing and producing working watches for the end collector is another. Add to the mix that you have included semi-precious gem stones as integral parts of the cog wheels in the drive train, and that there is no known way of doing this yet, and someone, somewhere along the way will have to come up with some very smart and original ideas. This is not just Richard’s triumph, but all the watchmakers and engineers at Richard Mille watches and Frédéric Garinaud’s team at AP Renaud and Papi who have developed and continue to develop the watch. Although the design is finalized, the watch remains in a constant state of development until the last of the special edition of 30 is completed. It is Richard Mille against the stone, and progress is wrought of attrition rather than a single moment of triumph.

When I first saw the initial drawings on the RM018 back in 2006, the drive train itself was composed of rose sapphires of various colours that would be finished into cog wheels. This proved to be an unworkable idea. It is not that the sapphire could not be fashioned into a cog wheel (quartz was also tried and would have provided a nice angle on the phrase ‘quartz watch’), but that the colour of the stone was lost when cut to a thickness of about a millemetre. Instead of the translucent colours of blue, green, or rose, there was only a clear or opaque veil of the colour, and while still interesting, was not the intended effect.

Since the initial idea, the switch was then made to semi-precious stones. Each watch, rather than being the same in terms of the stones used, would now have the drive train consisting of one type of stone. Each watch would be unique. With the change in the use of which stones to use, there was also a new set of problems to overcome. Chiefly, how to bind the semi-precious stone to the brass cog wheel element so that it would not come unstuck, that the stone would not stay still as the brass cog element freely moves with the others. The time keeping properties of the watch would be lost.

I have always argued that Richard Mille watches are where haute horologie meets the cutting edge of material science, and here he demonstrates this once again. The ability to bind a semi-precious stone to brass, so that the forces acting on the circumference of the stone where it meets the metal, is a unique solution. The problem in the solution is getting it right! The solution is one of trial and error, each and every time a new cog wheel is created. It is laborious, time consuming, and requires commitment to see this process through to the end product.

Each cog wheel is created thus. First, you select your semi-precious stone and machine a cylinder shape at the required diameter. Second, slice a part of the cylinder and then machine that to the required thickness. Polish, and finish to an exemplary standard. Third, obtain a piece of brass and drill a hole that is the same diameter as the circumference of the stone, only minus a very small (almost infinitesimally small) difference. Fourth, heat the brass plate with the hole so that the hole then expands to just larger than the diameter of the stone. Place the stone in the hole and allow the brass plate to cool (contracting the metal) so that the metal contracts around the stone, and equal pressure is applied at all times to the edge of the stone, thereby bind the stone to the metal. Cut out the cog wheel to the desired circumference and number of cogs.

[The basic building blocks: to create the cog wheels]



[A polished onyx wheel]





[The onyx wheel set within the brass plate]



Once the metal has cooled, and providing there are no further problems during the machining process, a cog wheel can be cut from the brass plate with the semi-precious stone set within.





Sounds so easy, so what can go wrong? Just about everything! At this level of micro engineering and materials science, the forces being considered are small, but still sufficient to cause problems. If the stone and the hole are not exactly circular in shape, then the forces acting on the stone are not constant and the stone can crack. If the stone is just too large for the brass hole, when the metal is allowed to contract, the stone will crack. As the exact composition is not known for the brass, the heating and cooling properties of the metal can only be approximated (remember we are dealing in dimensions of a micron here), and hence this can cause the stone to fall from the metal, or again, crack. The internal consistency of the stone is unknown; it may look perfect on the outside once polished, but inside may contain a minute fissure and once again, the stone can crack once the metal contracts around it. And so it goes on. The failure rate, even when the stone has passed the basic tests for its ability to be used in this process, is still very high. I asked, but was told that it was not known for sure. When I pressed for a ‘back of the envelope’ number, I was told it was upwards of a 90 percent failure rate. Each semi-precious cog wheel is a hard fought battle won.

[An example of a failure: once the metal had cooled, the onyx stone cracked]



More cog wheels are assembled than are needed as the watchmaker will choose which sets of wheels give the most aesthetically appealing configuration in the body of the watch. The watch is then assembled, with crystalline plates giving the impression that the movement is ‘floating’ in the centre of the watch case.

The computer rendition of the movement provides an idea of what is otherwise a simple tourbillon movement with a power reserve and off-centre secondhand, but that the movement is ‘held’ between the two plates with chatons providing the pins/pivots on which the jeweled cog wheels sit. Even getting the crystalline plates right, with the exact depth and drilled holes at the exact places without cracking the crystal plate, and then fixing the chatons, has also been time consuming and not without problems.





More posts: RM018

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

‘A Jewel of a Watch’: the Richard Mille RM018 ‘Hommage a Boucheron’.

 
 By: 219 : March 9th, 2010-12:53
The RM 018 "Hommage à Boucheron" represents the interesting union between jewelry and watch making, bringing the best of both worlds into one. Boucheron with exquisite jewelry design with Richard Mille’s revolutionary technical skills in watch making. Thi...  

Friends from Place Vendome

 
 By: 219 : March 9th, 2010-12:54
Early in 2006, with the 150th Anniversary of Boucheron around the corner, Richard and a former neighbour and friend on Place Vendome: Jean-Christophe Bedos (CEO of Boucheron) decided on a collaborative venture. To create a unique watch, a watch of substan...  

Perpetual Research

 
 By: 219 : March 9th, 2010-12:55
Showing a computer rendering of the watch to the world is one thing; developing and producing working watches for the end collector is another. Add to the mix that you have included semi-precious gem stones as integral parts of the cog wheels in the drive...  

They are making wagon-wheels!

 
 By: aaronm : March 9th, 2010-14:49
That "heat it and then let is cool down to apply compressive force" technique is exactly how tires (really steel rings) were put on wooden wagon wheels... I guess this would then qualify as "re-inventing the wheel" A

Inspiration can come from anywhere! True - and if

 
 By: 219 : March 11th, 2010-08:15
it worked well for the pioneers across America, it works well for pioneers in haute horologie! Thanks for reading. Andrew H

A Unique Watch in Every Sense.

 
 By: 219 : March 9th, 2010-12:56
The watch is unmistakably Richard Mille; it is unmistakably Boucheron. The tonneau case shape with the lateral struts, but with the Boucheron line pattern on the upper part of the case. As a synthesis it is genius. This watch has no parallel; it is for al...  

Stunning timepieces.

 
 By: VMM : March 9th, 2010-15:33
Saw them at the SIHH and found them very attractive. The colors from the wheels were very beautiful. Thanks for sharing. Vte

I think once all watches are assembled, it would be

 
 By: 219 : March 11th, 2010-08:16
fabulous to take pictures of all of them together. Personally waiting to see the lapis and the coral. Thanks Andrew H

Andrew, well done and thanks for sharing.

 
 By: Davo : March 9th, 2010-18:09
Always a pleasure to see these most beautiful pieces.

Thanks Andrew for this wonderful review!

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : March 9th, 2010-19:20
I can only imagine how tough it is to make these cog wheels. And a rejection rate of 90%? Not very cost effective but guess you got to do what you got to do to make the innards of the RM18. The red/pink coral and lapis versions will look amazing since the... 

Thanks Anthony - yes, all will carry the same engraving

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:02
on the top plate: it is the Boucheron case design. As I said, it is uniquely Boucheron; uniquely Richard Mille - and the case design reflects that - it is recognizeable as both. Andrew H

marvelous

 
 By: Tony A.H : March 10th, 2010-05:00
but my Heart is Aching righ now. sigh .so goegeous.!!!!!!!! Tony

You really should try to get to see one in the flesh...

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:12
so much more than my photos can convey. Thanks for reading Andrew H

Awesome RM report and pics Andrew!

 
 By: DRMW : March 10th, 2010-08:25
Lots of cool stuff from RM, thanks for keeping us updated! -MW

Finally rational....

 
 By: MTF : March 10th, 2010-19:49
I've always respected Richard Mille Watches and Renaud & Papi for their material science developments. The price-to-horology ratio?.....Not so much! Too expensive for what you get --- not optimum for regular collectors. But who said RM collectors are "reg... 

It is a winner - technically and aesthetically about as

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:32
far up the horological tree as you can go. Thanks for reading. Andrew H

I saw a press photo of the tiger's eye version...

 
 By: dxboon : March 10th, 2010-20:42
...in the summer of 2008, and thought the watch amazing then, as I do now. IMO the union of Boucheron and Richard Mille has brought forth remarkable fruit! The view into the skeletal heart of the watch is so airy and light-filled. I love the way light fil... 

Thank you for the kind words Daos - the watch when

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:35
held to the light, or worn on the wrist is truly a jewel. Not my taste - always loved the RM006 myself - but can appreciate what a masterpiece this is. Thanks again Andrew H

Thanks for the great report Andrew. Any idea

 
 By: SJX : March 11th, 2010-02:05
how the stone wheels will last over time? - SJX

As the stones are kept in place by frictional force, they should

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:38
last as long as any wheel in a watch. There has been testing on wear and tear and so far, once the wheel is set (and no cracks!!), the wheel is fine. Getting it right at the first instance is the all important tricky hurdle. Thanks Andrew H

Great post Andrew ...

 
 By: p@trice : March 11th, 2010-02:37
Thanks for sharing Best Patrice

It's not a juxtaposition one would normally expect . . .

 
 By: Dr No : March 11th, 2010-10:27
. . . but inside every technician, there lurks the heart of an artist ;-) . . .

Amasing...

 
 By: DonCorson : March 12th, 2010-10:53
I saw some wheels mounted with different stones at RM in Geneva 2 or 3 years ago and have been wondering if they were going to surface again. This is a great achievement. Using natural stone with all its inconsistancies is a real challenge. Great work and... 

Yes, the watch has had a full-time team for the last 3 years!!

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:43
It has taken an immense amount of patience, trial, effort to produce the two watches so far. The series when complete will be stunning, original, and truly a rare piece to be seen. Thanks Andrew H

Stunning.

 
 By: Davo : March 9th, 2010-18:08
And how much are those again?

A LOT! But considering the uniqueness, research, and originality

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:45
- its worth the price tag if you can afford the outlay! Andrew H

Wow... Those are beautiful...

 
 By: Chris Agostino : March 9th, 2010-19:47
I didn't think I would like the RM018 based on the original images that were released, but after seeing these photos I am totally smitten. They look fantastic. It is great to see that Richard Mille is not content to sit back and let his previous work defi... 

Great report...

 
 By: chris4 : March 10th, 2010-01:04
..thanks for the write up. Must admit I am a bit indifferant to this watch...love the movement and all the 'cleverness' in developing the piece, but cannot really get on with the case, would love to see it in a less shiny & less ribbed case!

But then it would not be 'Hommage a Boucheron'. It is a

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:49
jewelry piece and hence, I think it would be missing something if the case was not polished, was not the Boucheron case design. Thanks for reading Chris Andrew H

Richard, as we will see a little later this year, is perpetually

 
 By: 219 : March 16th, 2010-02:47
pushing the envelope. It is the very facet that makes his watches so exciting. Andrew H

Thanks a lot Andrew for the post.

 
 By: foversta : March 10th, 2010-14:02
The Boucheron style of the RM case works quite well I must confess. Shall I add that another surprise will come from Boucheron before the end of the year ? But a RM one. Fr.Xavier

Great post about the RM018 and the cog wheels

 
 By: ED209 : March 10th, 2010-21:14
Thanks Andrew for such an awesome post about the RM018. Those cog wheels using the onyx discs are amazing. I hope to see one in person some day. Regards, ED-209

Stunning

 
 By: Da Guru : July 21st, 2010-16:26
I like what is known today as 'bling' and this is of the cultured variety much like a baguette set rm12 I once owned.